Follow Us

Follow Me on Pinterest


Quick Local Dinner: Grilled Cheese and Tomato Soup

Grilled cheese and tomato soup

It’s been a quiet week in our kitchen. Lindsay and I were both sick, Lindsay has been travelling again for work, and we had out-of-town guests staying with us this past weekend. Meals at home were quick, and we mostly forgot to take photos. But, there is one exception: quick local grilled cheese sandwich and tomato soup.

Grilled Cheese and Tomato Soup


Amount Ingredient Preparation Where we bought it
(* Union Sq. Greenmarket)
1 loaf Homemade sourdough bread We’ll post the recipe once we get it right Flour from Cayuga Pure Organics *
~0.25 lb Swiss-style cheese Cut into 4 generous slices Cato Corner Farm *
1 TBsp Butter Melted 30 seconds in the microwave Ronnybrook Dairy *
1 Jar Whole tomatoes Cherry Lane Farms *
0.25 cup Cream Ronnybrook Dairy *


  1. Lindsay is experimenting with sourdough, but our first attempt at a starter fell kind of flat. Literally.

    The bread was still very tasty, just very dense. We cut and quartered it, and it worked well for what became grilled cheese paninis.

    Our unintentional flatbreadBread cut and quartered

  2. The cheese was a great swiss-style cheese from Cato Corner Farm. We used the better part of the 1/4 pound that we bought, cutting four generous slices.

    Cato Corners Swiss cheeseSandwich assembly

  3. We heated our stove top griddle on medium-low (no need for a griddle, it can just be a pan), and brushed the sandwiches with the melted butter.
  4. We used two cast iron pans to weigh the sandwiches down and press them as we grilled. I had the heat up a bit too high at this point and the sandwiches got a bit blackened.

    Pressing the sandwiches

  5. Lindsay heated a jar of canned whole tomatoes, mixed in a little cream, and attacked it with a stick blender. And in just one minute we had fresh, local, (nearly) sodium-free tomato soup!

    Jarred tomatoesHeating the tomatoes

2 comments to Quick Local Dinner: Grilled Cheese and Tomato Soup